What a wonderful world — if only Israel would go the hell away

by Jonathan Gurwitz, My San Antonio

As the so-called humanitarian flotilla approached Gaza late last month, Israeli military authorities attempted to warn the ships away from impending confrontation. “This is the Israeli navy,” they cautioned in radio transmissions. “You are approaching an area which is under a naval blockade.”

“Shut up. Go back to Auschwitz,” was the reply.

There may have been a good number of benevolent souls on those ships. But the heirs of Albert Schweitzer these were not.

Days before the flotilla incident, Rabbi David Nesenoff asked Helen Thomas, dean of the White House press corps, if she had any comments about Israel. “Tell them to get the hell out of Palestine.” Where should the Israelis — presumably the 5.7 million Jewish Israelis, not the country's 1.2 million Muslim citizens — go? “Poland. Germany. ... And America and everywhere else.”

For those of us who hope that Israelis and Palestinians will one day live as neighbors in peace and security, the clips of the radio exchange and the Thomas interview were enlightening — and depressing. Surely it's possible to recognize the humanity of one group and support its national aspirations without demanding the expulsion or extermination of the other, isn't it?

Perhaps not. For years, critics of Israel have wailed that any criticism of the Jewish state, no matter how muted, is met with charges of anti-Semitism. It's an argument that is ridiculous on its face, one that — like the false accusation of bigotry — is meant to discredit and squelch debate.

The most vibrant arguments about Israel take place within the Zionist community. The most vociferous critiques of Israeli policy occur within Israel itself. Take a look at the opinion pages of the online edition of the Jerusalem Post in recent days: “We need an international inquiry”; “Wanted: Israeli strategic long-term thinking.”

“Like a robot lacking in judgment, stuck on a predetermined path — that's how the government is behaving,” began an editorial in the daily Haaretz. As a thought experiment, imagine a journalist in Gaza writing similar words about Hamas without being thrown off the top of a building, or a journalist in Tehran criticizing the mullocracy without getting hanged.

Yet if it's false that any criticism of Israel is impermissible and is always met with charges of anti-Semitism, it is true that some of the obsession over the small parcel of land Jews have called home for 3,000 years, the effort to delegitimize Israel alone among the nations, the elevation of Palestinian human rights above Tibetan and Chechan and all other human rights, the accusations of apartheid that somehow overlook entire Saudi cities that are forbidden to non-believers, the preoccupation with Israeli misdeeds while ignoring actual genocides elsewhere is ... well, hard to explain.

Maybe the people with these compulsions have completely benign intentions. Maybe they really do care about the welfare of Palestinians, despite the fact that Hamas represents a fundamentalist threat to the Palestinian Authority. Maybe they truly mean it when they say that their criticism of Israel is a sincere expression of caring, even if they have an odd way of showing it.

Or perhaps just below the surface, on a radio frequency they think no one will ever hear or in an interview they presume no one will ever see, something else is at work.

Perhaps they just wish the Jews would go the hell away ... somewhere, anywhere other than where they are. Perhaps their greatest lament about the Holocaust is that the Nazis didn't do a better job. And perhaps their hope is that if they can confound decent people long enough with their professions of humanitarianism, Hamas or Hezbollah or a nuclear-armed Iran will finally be able to finish what Hitler did not.



Copyright © Jewish Internet Defense Force
All Rights Reserved

LEGAL:
The views expressed on this website do not necessarily reflect the views of the JIDF. The content is not intended to malign any religion, ethnic group, club, organization, company or individual. This site's intention is to do no harm, to not injure others, defame, or libel. All data and information provided on this site is for informational, educational, and/or entertainment purposes only. The Jewish Internet Defense Force (JIDF) makes no representations as to accuracy, currentness, correctness, suitability, or validity of any information on this site and will not be liable for any errors, omissions, or delays in this information or any losses, injuries, or damages arising from its display or use, or access to this site. We are not responsible for translation or interpretation of content. We are not responsible for defamatory statements bound to government, religious or other laws from the reader’s country of origin. All information is provided on an as-is basis with no warranties, and confers no rights. We are not responsible for the actions, content, accuracy, opinions expressed, privacy policies, products or services or for any damages or losses, directly or indirectly, caused or alleged to have been caused as a result of your use or reliance on such information on the Jewish Internet Defense Force site. This site includes links to other sites and blogs operated by third parties. These links are provided as a convenience to you and as an additional avenue of access to the information contained therein. We have not reviewed all of the information on other sites and are not responsible for the content of any other sites or any products or services that may be offered through other sites. The inclusion of these links in no way indicates their endorsement, support or approval of the contents of this site or the policies or positions of the JIDF. We have the right to edit, remove or deny access to content that is determined to be, in our sole discretion, unacceptable. These Terms and Conditions of Use apply to you when you view, access or otherwise use this blog and the Website. The JIDF is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.
Related Posts with Thumbnails